top of page

Thwarted in Death

  • Writer: Lawrence Lore
    Lawrence Lore
  • Mar 2
  • 2 min read

Let’s set the scene: John Pargin, feeling a bit under the weather (and perhaps sensing the Grim Reaper lurking nearby), wrote his Will on March 11, 1821. He didn’t know it, but he was about to become a local celebrity—the first person to have a Will filed in the brand-new County of Lawrence. Not exactly the kind of “first” most people aim for, but hey, history is history.


In his Will, John assured everyone he was still of sound mind, though his body was apparently less enthusiastic. He named his wife, Cossier Pargin, as one of his executors—a bold move in an era when most men thought women’s business expertise ended at pie crusts. But John was practical (and probably knew who really ran the household).


The bequests? Oh, they were classic:

  • To his son Peter: a young sorrel mare, a rifle, and a steel trap. Clearly, Peter was set for a life of adventure—or at least well-equipped to chase squirrels and outlaws.

  • To his daughter Nancy: the old sorrel mare and a cow. Not quite as glamorous, but hey, a cow is a cow. (Let’s hope Nancy was a fan of dairy.)

  • To his three youngest, Polly, John, and Jacob: one hundred dollars’ worth of land each. Because nothing says “I love you” like a patch of dirt.


The rest of the estate? All for Cossier—but only as long as she remained a “widder.” If she remarried, the kids got the leftovers. (A not-so-subtle nudge from beyond the grave: “Don’t rush into anything, dear.”)


After signing with his mark (“x”—the original minimalist signature), John departed this world. Cossier took charge, Peter rode off into the sunset with his new gear, and Nancy presumably tried to look happy with her slightly used horse and her cow.


But the real twist?  Mrs. Pargin? Cossier did not remain in the state of ‘widderhood’ for a great length of time. About a year later, the ‘widder’ Crossier Pargin became Mrs. Casiah Barney on July 3, 1822 and John's desire that she never love another was . . .thwarted. Oh Well.

Recent Posts

See All
An Exhibition of Ladies’ Limbs. . .

Friday, April 15th, 1881 The editor hoped the groundhog would never live to see his shadow again! Sunday was Easter and every little boy and girl in the land wanted to celebrate the time-honored event

 
 
Jesse Lancaster, Naturalized Citizen

The Lawrence County Court Records include Naturalization Records, and while these records are not commonplace in this county, they do exist. Before the 1870 census Jesse Lancaster left England and se

 
 
Charity Resulted in Death

Ashulamite was the daughter of Wabash County pioneers Peter Keen and Jemima Gard. Ashulamite Keen was married first to Caleb Jordan in 1821 and then to Joseph Lamotte, Jr. in 1832. The Lamotte's a

 
 

     Call us:

618-943-3870

Email:

 lawrencelore@gmail.com

  • Facebook page

JOIN OUR FREE BLOG SUBSCRIPTION!

Thanks for subscribing!

© Lawrence County Historical Society 2025. All Rights Reserved.

bottom of page